Skip to content

Cross-post: My Trans Fat Story

June 24, 2024

Just so you know ahead of time, I’m not referring to the naughty substance.

I’m referring to the naughty identity. I am a gender-bending small fat person.

All my life I have loved being a girl, but always felt incomplete. Inside of me is not just a girl, but a boy. I longed to be tall, big, strong, and to live my life as a man at various points in my life. When I was little and my friends and I were playing house, I gladly played the father. As a teenager, I started singing and discovered that I have a contralto voice. I am capable of singing male parts as low as the top range of Bass I and as high as the bottom range of Soprano I. My sister used to love to tell me I was built like a lumberjack. When I began to grow breasts, it caused me depression and anxiety and I used to stand in front of the mirror and claw at them. At night, I would wear the smallest bras as tight as I could in the hope that they would stop growing.

Finally, at 14 I began gender-bending and I discovered that I can make myself look and act very much like a man, such that people actually mistake me for one on the street or do not recognize me if they know me. I was raised in a small conservative town, so I wasn’t in good company and even people who ordinarily are in favor of gay and lesbian inclusion or people expressing themselves in general did not like me as a man.* To say the least, my parents absolutely hated it.

Hated it.

Hated it.

Did I mention that my parents hated that their daughter was androgynous? And that people, oh my good golly gosh, KNEW about it?

They thought I was depressed and that there was something wrong with me or how they raised me. They would talk about me in hushed tones when they thought I couldn’t hear. You know, that wicked aggravating hushed tone parents use when they have no clue what they’re doing or talking about, but they need to have a good story to tell or something to start with so they can “be strong.”

It got worse as I got taller, more muscular, and, yes, fatter. Every shoe size up was another step away from the feminine ideal I had been taught to aspire to. I grew so fast one year that I developed a scoliotic deformity and a limp, and my mother was so ashamed that she did not want to take me to the doctor and simply told me to stand up straight. Aside from being unattractive in itself and being mildly crippling, it shifts your proportions and can make you appear fatter than you are.

To make a long story short, I am now a proud gender-bender. I live most of my life as a casually-dressed woman, but I can also be androgynous, feminine, sporty feminine, hyperfeminine, as well as formally and sporty masculine. These are all categories I made up to describe the different gender presentations I can adopt. My father now proudly takes me shopping for men’s clothes and my mother is grudgingly accepting my tomboy side (sporty masculine).

The best news of all is that while my size and shape once caused me grief, it is now a magnificent addition to my gender-bending lifestyle. I cannot speak for gender-benders who are larger or smaller than me, but being my size — a small fat person — I have found my body endlessly adaptable.

Some of the assets of my size are:

  • Larger curves to work with when applicable to wearing corsets, form-fitting clothes, and lingerie
  • The ability to alter size perception downward (i.e., by wearing black or pinstripes for a leaner look or binding to minimize breast size)
  • Height and muscularity for masculine roles (I am very muscular)
  • Height can be useful in supermodel-type roles
  • Having large feet makes me look good in men’s dress shoes, feminine dress boots, and chunky heels
  • Scoliosis and altered body proportions make it super easy to imitate male gait and assume a “tough” posture
  • Because my hair is long, I can wear it feminine (long) or masculine (short or tucked under a wig).

For the record, I am not saying that only women can have long hair or that women with little feet can’t wear chunky heels. I am just saying that for the roles I adopt, my physical features happen to be well-adapted to the clothes I seek for those roles. Everyone presents differently when they go gender-bending.

The only downside is shopping for clothes. I have no problem in the men’s department, except that I’m not used to their sizing scheme. Shopping for cute women’s clothes can be harder because I am sized out of many of the best-looking clothes, partly because of height and weight, but also proportions. Believe it or not, the absolute best place to buy clothes is in costume shops or department stores around Halloween, especially if you are a flamboyant gender-bender.

People often crossdress for Halloween to emulate favorite characters, so it’s not uncommon to find one-size-fits-all costumes for both genders. For those of you who are not flamboyant, or who are not in the mood to be flamboyant at the moment, I would still recommend buying clothes around Halloween because you can mix and match, take things apart or put them together, for something less aggressive. I have SO many clothes that double as Halloween costumes and you could never tell the difference.

I still have trouble cross-dressing in public, but being open about it and using my body, my voice, and all my features to my advantage makes it feel natural to me. Knowing where to find other cross-dressers helps, and alternative sexual communities are usually much more accepting of different bodies and abilities than the vanilla sex scene.

Everyone in FA has done it, struggled about exercising the right to be you, and every day, it becomes easier to just be me.

How did you be you today? Any other GBs in the house?

*I would think that people who support gays, lesbians, and transgender people would accept androgynous people and crossdressers, but I guess some people are NIMBY types. They are all for it if they don’t know you personally.

5 Comments leave one →
  1. FabAt54 permalink
    June 24, 2024 11:51 am

    I really don’t have much to say in particular…. except that this post made me smile. It’s so nice to read about / from someone who is honestly satisfied (if not downright happy!) about who they are and how they look. You *are* beautiful.

  2. Lucy Curtis permalink
    June 24, 2024 1:53 pm

    That’s wonderful. Even in FA I haven’t seen a lot of “Some of the assets of my size are:” lists and I think those are good things to have. This post does a great job of demonstrating how to be proud of yourself without being down on people who are of a different size.

  3. JoannaDW permalink
    June 24, 2024 3:21 pm

    Thanks for the sentiments, guys. I really appreciate it. I wasn’t sure how it would be received because I didn’t want people thinking that I was telling them how to dress or how to be.

  4. Faycin A Croud permalink
    June 24, 2024 5:20 pm

    Although I am a straight woman in that I am attracted to men, I’ve always thought of myself as a “fabulous gay man trapped in the body of a frumpy straight woman.” I feel like I really get gay men. Not all gay men engage in drag, of course, but I love drag queens. In this sense I’ve always felt that I was a little bit “queer” in spite of being straight. It isn’t a sexual turn-on for me, it’s just that I don’t “think” like a woman except with the belief that being a mother is the most important thing in my life.
    Notice that I said in MY life. I do not believe that a woman is only a “real woman” if she’s a mother. Far from it. I think it’s sad if someone feels forced into becoming a parent by their family and by society. Not everyone wants kids.
    I don’t mind being female, but I’ve been called a dyke more than once because I am not a “girly girl.” I don’t like going shopping for the latest fashions, I want something comfortable. I don’t want to be a man in the sense that I want a gender change. I’m actually fine with being a gay man in a straight woman’s body! I know that most people won’t get that, but I think you do. I also love that you were so honest about who you are. Cheers!

  5. vesta44 permalink
    June 27, 2024 12:55 pm

    I so get this. I’ve never really fit in with most women that I knew - I’m not a girly girl, never have been, have always been more of a tomboy. I grew up working on cars, hunting with my dad, fishing, riding horses, taking care of the dog. Yeah, I did housework because my mother forced me into it, but I hated it with the heated passion of a thousand suns. To this day I hate to cook and do dishes, and I could care less if the house is spotless. However, my car had better be clean and it had better be in top running condition and I know what it takes to make sure that happens (I went to college to become an auto mechanic). I refuse to wear dresses (don’t own any) and fashion doesn’t mean much to me but comfort is important (most of the time, you’ll find me in jeans and tee shirts or something similar). The last time I dressed up, got my hair done, and wore make-up was for my son’s wedding almost 5 years ago (I didn’t even do all of that for my own wedding) and even then, I didn’t wear a dress, I wore a pantsuit that I made.
    Not all women have to be feminine, we can be anything we want to be along the spectrum from feminine to masculine to androgynous and it’s fine, or it should be, anyway. Makes life more interesting, is the way I see it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 324 other followers

Powered by WordPress.com